by Paul Dao
09.02.2025
Table of contents
Make an appointment with
our experts
How to calculate the amount of your French pension
Make an appointment

Shares vs Bonds in Pillar 3a

Investing in pillar 3a in Switzerland involves choosing between shares and bonds, two types of assets with very distinct characteristics. Equities offer high growth potential over the long term, but with significant volatility. Bonds, on the other hand, favor stability and a predictable, although more modest, return. The key to Optimize your retirement savings ? A balanced distribution between these two asset classes, adapted to your risk tolerance and your investment horizon.

Key points:

  • Actions : High returns, but more risks and fluctuations. Ideal for a long horizon.
  • Bonds : Increased security, stable returns, but often lower than inflation. Suitable for cautious profiles or those close to retirement.
  • Mandatory diversification : Dividing your investments between stocks, bonds and other assets is essential to limit risks.
  • Regulatory limits : Pillar 3a imposes a maximum share of actions to reduce market exposure.

Tip: Reassess your portfolio regularly and adjust it according to your goals and market conditions. A thoughtful approach can maximize your tax savings and make your savings grow in the long term.

Actions in Pillar 3a: Characteristics, Benefits and Risks

What are Actions and their Characteristics

Shares represent ownership shares in companies listed on the stock exchange. Investing in shares via pillar 3a makes you a shareholder, thus directly participating in the growth and success of these companies. This type of investment is distinguished by its long-term return potential, which makes it a particularly interesting option for a extended investment horizon like that of pillar 3a.

However, the actions are also marked by a significant volatility, reflecting price fluctuations due to a variety of factors such as business results, economic conditions, or market feelings. While these variations may seem worrisome in the short term, they offer opportunities for significant growth over the long term.

By diversifying your investments with stocks from different regions of the world, you can also reduce the risks associated with a single market while taking advantage of global economic dynamics.

Benefits of Investing in Shares

Investing in stocks has several attractive benefits, including their long-term growth potential. Historically, stock markets have outperformed inflation over long periods of time, which helps maintain and even increase the purchasing power of your retirement savings.

Another key advantage is their resilience in the face of inflation. Unlike fixed income investments, businesses can adjust prices and earnings based on changing costs, protecting your capital from the loss of value caused by inflation.

The time horizon of pillar 3a, often several decades, is ideal for taking advantage of these benefits. This duration makes it possible to absorb short-term fluctuations and to maximize the potential gains generated by business growth.

In addition, many businesses pay dividends, which constitute an appreciable complement to performance. These regular payments, while not guaranteed, can be reinvested to strengthen the capitalization effect and increase the overall return on your portfolio.

Stock Risks

Despite their benefits, stocks also come with risks that are essential to understand before investing.

The main risk is Market volatility. Stock prices can change significantly over short periods of time, which can lead to temporary losses. These fluctuations, while unavoidable, require risk tolerance and a long-term vision.

Les economic cycles also influence the performance of equities. During periods of recession, businesses often see their profits decline, which can negatively affect their stock prices. These phases can last several months or even years and require patience on the part of investors.

There is also a risk of capital loss. Unlike bonds that pay back the principal at maturity, stocks offer no guarantee that your initial investment will be recovered. In the most serious cases, a company may go bankrupt, causing a total loss of investment in its securities.

Finally, the actions are sensitive to geopolitical events. Conflicts, health crises, trade tensions, or sudden regulatory changes can cause sudden declines in financial markets.

Another factor that should not be overlooked is the impact of emotions on decision-making. The temptation to sell during downturns or to buy when markets are at peak levels can hurt your long-term returns. Disciplined management and a thoughtful approach are essential to avoid these pitfalls.

These elements highlight the importance of a diversification and a balanced allocation in your pillar 3a investment strategy. This makes it possible to manage risks while taking advantage of the opportunities offered by equities.

Everything you need to know about the 3rd pillar in Switzerland ¦ ↘️ Taxes ↗️ Wealth

Pillar 3a Obligations: Characteristics, Benefits and Risks

After discovering the dynamism of equities, let's take a look at the stability that bonds can offer under pillar 3a.

What are Bonds and their Characteristics

Bonds are financial instruments where you lend money to businesses or governments in exchange for a set return. In pillar 3a, they often take the form of 3a interest-bearing accounts, offered by banks or insurance companies. These solutions focus on security, with interest rates that are generally more attractive than a traditional savings account. Their main advantage lies in their predictability: you know in advance the interest rate, the duration and the date of repayment of the principal. Sometimes bonds are integrated into 3a investment funds, playing a stabilizing role within the portfolio.

Benefits of Investing in Bonds

Bonds offer significant capital protection and security, thus reducing the overall volatility of a portfolio. They are a reliable basis for saving for retirement. Unlike stocks, they have almost no risk of loss. This reassuring nature makes them particularly suitable for cautious investors or those nearing retirement age.

Bond risks

However, this security comes with limited return potential. While stocks can generate higher gains over the long term, bonds make do with smaller returns. That's why it's essential to properly balance their portion of your portfolio in order to reach your financial goals.

Sbb-ITB-505FA4B

Shares vs Bonds in Pillar 3a: Direct Comparison

After exploring the characteristics of stocks and bonds, let's move on to a direct comparison to better adjust your pillar 3a strategy. Based on the diversification principles mentioned above, let's look at how these two types of assets complement each other under pillar 3a.

Comparison criteria

To fully understand the differences between stocks and bonds, here is a table that summarizes their performance according to several key criteria:

Criteria Actions Bonds Yield potential High, reflecting long-term growth potential Moderate, with more stable and predictable returns Risk Level Important, due to their volatility Weak, offering more stability for capital Inflation protection Good in the long term thanks to their growth Limited, as fixed returns are sensitive to inflation Liquidity Good, but dependent on market fluctuations Excellent, with a more stable value Regulatory constraints Limitation of the share of shares in pillar 3a No specific restrictions Investment horizon Adapted to long-term strategies More suitable for the short or medium term Risk tolerance required Request acceptance of market fluctuations Better suited for investors looking for stability

Analysis and Implications

The table highlights marked differences between stocks and bonds, especially in terms of return, risk, and inflation protection. These distinctions directly influence their relevance according to your investment horizon and your risk tolerance.

  • Investment horizon : Equities are ideal for a long term horizon, as they offer greater growth potential, even if they are more volatile. Conversely, bonds, with their stability, are better suited to shorter periods or closer to retirement, when preserving capital becomes a priority.
  • Impact of inflation : Equities, thanks to their capacity for growth, protect better against inflation in the long term. Bonds, with their fixed returns, can erode during periods of high inflation, making them less efficient at this level.
  • Regulatory constraints : Pillar 3a imposes a limit on the share of shares, thus encouraging balanced diversification. This rule aims to reduce exposure to market fluctuations while allowing the benefits of both asset classes to be enjoyed.

Finally, your psychological profile plays a crucial role: some investors are more tolerant of temporary declines and expect higher returns, while others prefer a more conservative approach to maintain their peace of mind.

By taking these elements into account, you can develop a balanced mix of stocks and bonds that is tailored to your financial goals and risk tolerance.

Creating a Balanced Pillar 3a Portfolio

To take advantage of the benefits and risks of stocks and bonds, it is essential to build a well-thought-out and adaptable strategy. A balanced portfolio is based on an asset allocation adapted to your investor profile and the specificities of pillar 3a.

How to Allocate Shares and Bonds

The key to a successful distribution between stocks and bonds lies in your risk tolerance and your investment horizon. By evaluating these elements, you can define an allocation that fits your needs. Consider several factors: your investment experience, your ability to bear losses, and how long you can let your money grow. If you are ready for major fluctuations and have a long time horizon, a greater share of actions may be considered.

Pillar 3a investment solutions offer flexibility with equity allocations ranging from 15% to 97%, allowing you to adjust your portfolio according to your profile. If you are close to retirement, a more careful approach with a smaller share of shares is often a good idea. Conversely, if retirement is still a long way off, a more growth-oriented strategy may be considered.

Diversification is a legal requirement for pillar 3a assets. This means that your investments should be spread across multiple asset classes, such as Swiss and international equities, bonds, real estate, commodities, and cash. This approach reduces the risk of underperforming a single type of investment.

In general, securities investment solutions offer greater potential for long-term returns thanks to the effect of compound interest. On the other hand, pillar 3a savings accounts often offer rates under 1%. Additionally, investing in assets like stocks can protect your capital against inflation.

Once your allocation is defined, it is crucial to adjust it regularly according to market fluctuations.

Adapting to Market Changes

To keep your portfolio in line with your goals, periodic adjustments are necessary. An annual review is recommended. If an asset class deviates from its target by 5 to 10%, it is time to rebalance. For example, if your target allocation is 60% equities and 40% bonds, but equities reach 70% after a strong performance, it is advisable to readjust.

These adjustments should also take into account your personal circumstances. An increase in income, a change in your retirement goals, or a change in your risk tolerance may require a review of your benefit.

Use Professional Financial Services

Hiring financial experts can simplify the management of your pillar 3a portfolio. These professionals help you define a strategy adapted to your situation, taking into account factors such as age, investment horizon, risk tolerance and financial goals.

Best Third Pillar offers personalized services, including free simulations, consultations with experts and continuous monitoring of your strategy. These tools allow you to calculate your tax savings, to project your retirement capital and to receive targeted recommendations.

Financial advisors also play a crucial role in providing objective advice, helping you avoid impulsive decisions, and adjusting your strategy based on market conditions. A study showed that 17% of investors call on a professional mainly to benefit from behavioral support.

An advisor's expertise is invaluable in identifying investment opportunities and ensuring that your assets are aligned with your goals. In addition, a financial advisor must put your interests first by offering transparent recommendations.

To optimize your portfolio, schedule at least one annual meeting with your advisor. This will allow you to adjust your strategy according to the evolution of your personal situation and market conditions.

Conclusion: Shares vs Bonds in Pillar 3a

The choice between investing in shares or bonds under pillar 3a is based on the specific advantages of each asset type. Stocks, for example, offer long-term growth potential, which can not only offset the effects of inflation, but also maximize your retirement savings. On the other hand, bonds play a stabilizing role by protecting part of your capital against market fluctuations.

One of the great advantages of pillar 3a is the flexibility it offers in terms of allocation. You can adjust your portfolio according to your risk tolerance, investment horizon, and financial goals. These elements often change over time, making regular monitoring and adjustments essential to stay in line with your personal circumstances and market conditions.

Diversification is also a fundamental pillar to protect your capital while optimizing the relationship between risk and return. Good diversification under pillar 3a reduces the risks associated with excessive dependence on a single asset type or sector.

To refine your strategy, it can be helpful to consult financial experts. Best Third Pillar, for example, offers free simulation tools and personalized consultations to help you determine the ideal allocation based on your situation. These resources can simplify your decisions and allow you to effectively follow your investment strategy.

Finally, to stay in line with your retirement goals, remember to reassess your portfolio regularly. Markets change, as do your needs, and frequent rebalancing is essential to maintain a strategy in line with your long-term financial ambitions.

FAQs

How do I choose the right distribution between shares and bonds in my pillar 3a according to my risk tolerance and my investment horizon?

To determine how to allocate shares and bonds in your pillar 3a, it is essential to assess your risk tolerance. It comes down to examining how ready you are, emotionally and financially, to deal with market changes. Another key factor is your investment horizon, which is how many years you have left before retirement. The longer this horizon, the more relevant it may be to include a high proportion of shares in your portfolio. Indeed, equities offer the potential for higher returns, but they come with greater volatility.

One method that is often used is the “100 minus your age” rule. For example, if you are 40, you could consider investing 60% of your portfolio in stocks and 40% in bonds. That said, this rule is not set in stone and can be adjusted according to your specific goals and personal risk tolerance. If you are unsure, it may be helpful to consult a financial expert or use online simulators to define a strategy that fits your situation. Customized solutions, such as those offered by Best Third Pillar, can also help you optimize your portfolio while taking into account your unique needs.

What are the tax advantages of pillar 3a in Switzerland and how can they influence my investment strategy?

Pillar 3a contributions in Switzerland are a great way to reduce your tax bill while saving for your retirement. Indeed, these contributions are deductible from your taxable income, which directly reduces the amount of your taxes. Let's take a concrete example: in 2025, employees will be able to deduct up to CHF 7,258. This is a great opportunity to reduce your taxes while strengthening your savings.

In addition to tax savings, investments made under pillar 3a benefit from tax-free growth until they are withdrawn. This double advantage — immediate tax savings and long-term returns without intermediate taxation — makes it a powerful tool for building a financial strategy that is aligned with your future goals.

How does diversification in pillar 3a contribute to reducing risks while increasing long-term returns?

Diversification under pillar 3a consists of dividing your investments between different asset classes, such as shares, the obligations And the real estate funds. The objective? Reduce risks by preventing the poor performance of a single asset from affecting your entire portfolio too heavily.

By combining riskier assets, like stocks, with more stable options, like bonds, you can not only mitigate volatility but also aim for better returns over the long term. This strategy plays a key role in protecting your retirement savings while taking advantage of its growth potential.

Related blog posts

{” @context “:” https://schema.org","@type":"FAQPage","mainEntity":[{"@type":"Question","name":"Comment choosing the right distribution between shares and bonds in my pillar 3a according to my risk tolerance and my investment horizon?” <strong>, "AcceptedAnwer”: {” @type “: “Answer”, "Answer”, "text”:” To determine how to allocate stocks and bonds in your pillar 3a, it is essential to assess your risk tolerance.</strong> <p> It comes down to examining how ready you are, emotionally and financially, to deal with market changes. Another key factor is your investment horizon, which is how many years you have left before retirement. The longer this horizon, the more relevant it may be to include a high proportion of shares in your portfolio. Indeed, equities offer the potential for higher returns, but they come with greater volatility.</p> <p>One method that is often used is the “100 minus your age” rule. For example, if you are 40, you could consider investing 60% of your portfolio in stocks and 40% in bonds. That said, this rule is not set in stone and can be adjusted according to your specific goals and personal risk tolerance. If you are unsure, it may be helpful to consult a financial expert or use online simulators to define a strategy that fits your situation. Customized solutions, such as those offered by Best Third Pillar, can also help you optimize your portfolio while taking into account your unique needs.</p> “}}, {” @type “: Question”, "name”: “What are the tax advantages of pillar 3a in Switzerland and how can they influence my investment strategy?” , "AcceptedAnwer”: {” @type “: “Answer”, "Answer”, "text”:” <p>Pillar 3a contributions in Switzerland are a great way to reduce your tax bill while saving for your retirement. Indeed, these contributions are deductible from your taxable income, which directly reduces the amount of your taxes. Let's take a concrete example: in 2025, employees will be able to deduct up to <strong>7,258 CHF</strong>. This is a great opportunity to reduce your taxes while strengthening your savings</p>. <p>In addition to tax savings, investments made under pillar 3a benefit from tax-free growth until they are withdrawn. This double advantage — immediate tax savings and long-term returns without intermediate taxation — makes it a powerful tool for building a financial strategy that is aligned with your future goals</p>. “}}, {” @type “: Question”, "name”: “How does diversification in pillar 3a contribute to reducing risks while increasing long-term returns?” <strong><strong>, "AcceptedAnwer”: {” @type “: Answer”, "Answer”, "text”:” Diversification under pillar 3a consists of distributing your investments across different asset classes, such as <strong>stocks</strong>, bonds, and real estate funds.</strong></strong> <p> The objective? Reduce risks by preventing the poor performance of a single asset from affecting your entire portfolio too heavily</p>. <p>By combining riskier assets, like stocks, with more stable options, like bonds, you can not only mitigate volatility but also aim for better returns over the long term. This strategy plays a key role in protecting your retirement savings while taking advantage of its growth potential.</p> “}}]}